The kite runner by khaled hosseini, one bullet away. Such was the resolute promise of world leaders after the 911. What the frontier of afghanistan tells us about the war. Her new book is bravely situated in afghanistan itself, eroding the myth of the good occupier and of what is termed in the novel kind power.
This epic threevolume masterpiece is to war what gibbons decline and fall of the roman empire was to history. Tomsen thus interacted with many players of the 1980s afghan civil war, as no other american probably has. The first phasetoppling the taliban the ultraconservative political and religious faction that ruled afghanistan and provided sanctuary for alqaeda, perpetrators of the september 11 attackswas brief, lasting just two months. Feb 26, 2018 the title is important, because this book about what we call the afghanistan war is as much about pakistan as it is about afghanistan. Thirteen years into the afghan invasion, the americans lack a. The mujahideen were backed primarily by the united states. Thirteen years into the afghan invasion, the americans.
While afghanistan is a war of sorts, it is not the sort of war in which there is likely to be a decisive moment of victory. List of books and articles about afghan history online. Score a book s total score is based on multiple factors, including the number of people who have voted for it and how highly those voters ranked the book. This is a portrait of a junior officer grappling with the weight of war and coming to terms with what it means to lead others in combat. There are graphic descriptions of an adulterous woman being stoned to death based on an execution that michener actually saw and of another public execution where a young man gets his head slowly sawn off with a rusty bayonet again based on an actual event, though michener wasnt an. The theory was presented in many ways, but its core argument was this. Afghanistan war has cost every british household more than. The trump administration announced in late february that a peace deal was being negotiated with the taliban and there was intention of recalling u. Afghanistan war, international conflict beginning in 2001 that was triggered by the september 11 attacks.
Why we couldnt win the war or the peace in afghanistan jack. In 1979, a year after a coup, the soviet army invaded afghanistan to. He says the united states will stick to a timetable to draw down most combat forces. By 1979 guerrilla opposition forces, popularly called mujahidin islamic warriors, were active in much of the country, fighting both soviet forces and the sovietbacked afghan government. Popular afghanistan war books meet your next favorite book. A searing look at the true cost of americas good war in afghanistan. As the french might say, this is no quelle surprise. Haass, whose latest book explores president george w. His work is all the more powerful for this, yet there is no lack of either humour or poignancy. As the us and its allies quietly withdraw their troops from afghanistan though more. The mujahideen were backed primarily by the united states, saudi arabia, pakistan. Afghanistan war, international conflict in afghanistan beginning in 2001 that was triggered by the september 11 attacks and consisted of three phases. How the military campaign in afghanistan began with clear aims and robust.
The book is very good to read, full of pace and drama. Why we couldnt win the war or the peace in afghanistan jack fairweather jonathan cape, 512pp. Jul 31, 2017 no white house wants to lose a war, especially one that has its provenance in 1980 with the decision to arm the afghan mujahedeen against the invading soviet army and in 2001 with the u. Of course, this is the point when you think, the military. Why we couldnt win the war or the peace in afghanistan by jack fairweather delves into what went wrong on the various mission attempts by a vast variety of players in afghanistan. The making of a marine officer by nathaniel fick, war by sebastian. Only a few hundred al qaeda militants are estimated to be active in afghanistan, and they play a minor role in armed attacks against nato forces. Danny sjursen, an author and historian who spent half of his life in the army, speaks with.
In 1979, a year after a coup, the soviet army invaded afghanistan to support its communist government. Dec 15, 2019 in 2014, gopals book on afghanistan, no good men among the living. Lessons from vietnam on leaving afghanistan theres no good way to end a bad war, but some options are worse than others. Obama reaffirms campaign statements that afghanistan is the more important u. Afghanistan had been in a state of almost constant war for 20 years even before the us invaded. Why we couldnt win the war or the peace in afghanistan. Afghanistan war, 2001personal narratives, afghanistan war. Danny sjursen, an author and historian who spent half of his. The book is set in afghanistan in around 1946, but things havent changed much in that barbaric country. The setting is a small mountainous village in 2009. The book tracks the invasions impact upon a handful of diverse afghan figures.
It is a devastating, wellhoned prosecution detailing how our government bungled the initial salvo in the socalled war on terror, ignored attempts by top taliban leaders to surrender, trusted the wrong people and backed a feckless and corrupt afghan regime. In 1988, the soviet army left afghanistan after a concerted campaign by the westernbacked mujahideen. Jan 23, 2015 this article is more than 5 years old in his state of the union address, president obama touted the end of the u. Obama broadening afghanistan war into war of choice and. The war in afghanistan is a fraud and now we have proof. Medal of honor recipient john chapman and the untold story of the worlds deadliest. War in afghanistan 2001present part of the larger afghanistan conflict, and the global war on terrorism. Jack fairweather has shown himself to be a narrative historian of the first order. The united states has been fighting a war in afghanistan for over 18 years. Afghanistan war, 2001, individual wars, nook books barnes.
America, the taliban, and the war through afghan eyes by. Craig mullaney recounts the hard lessons that only war can teach while fighting alqaeda in afghanistan. The united states won a quick victory, drove the taliban and al qaeda out, and installed a friendly government. The afghanistan papers show that not only has the 20year war been wasteful of human life, its also been wasteful of money. In the course of the iraq and afghanistan wars, military strategists in the united states developed the concept of the long war. The sovietafghan war was a conflict wherein insurgent groups known collectively as the mujahideen, as well as smaller maoist groups, fought a guerrilla war against the soviet army and the democratic republic of afghanistan government for over nine years, throughout the 1980s, mostly in the afghan countryside. Afghan civil war 199296, leads to the taliban controlling most of afghanistan, with the northern alliance controlling northern afghanistan.
Such was the resolute promise of world leaders after the 911 attacks that provoked an invasion of. He saw moments like last monday coming more than a halfcentury ago and had the good sense to put them in a book of satire i cant help but wish more people used as their guidebook to war. Afghanistan war, 2001, individual wars, nook books. A novel set in afghanistan challenges the myth of the good. After all, i could hardly write a thing down about my iraq war experience for nearly ten years, when, by accident, i churned out a book on the subject. The united states and the failure of nation building in pakistan, afghanistan, and central asia by ahmed rashid, is also looking at afghanistans international relationships, but this time in the modern day. No british officer should be allowed to board a plane for our next war until. He understood the region, spoke the languages of the combatants, and was cool under fire. May 30, 20 the war in afghanistan has cost every british household more than. As americas longest war inches closer to an end pending coronavirus as a result of donald trumps deal with the taliban in march, commentators are furnishing autopsies of how the socalled good war in afghanistan hasnt lived up to its moniker after nearly two decades of stalemate. Why america loses every war it starts, the outcomes that followed in vietnam, iraq after 2003 and a number of. This article is more than 5 years old in his state of the union address, president obama touted the end of the u.
The overall hope of such analysis is to go forward and not create the same mistakes of those in the past. In the beginning, afghanistan looked like a good war. It is the definitive history of the us civil war it gives equal treatment to both sides, and is more than one million words, but is never boring. Mar 19, 2020 nearly 19 years into the afghanistan war, it seems the u.
Jacobin s jason farbman sat down with gopal to discuss the machinations of us empire, the bipartisan roots of the afghanistan disaster, and the socialist. When british india was partitioned 1947, afghanistan wanted the pathans of the northwest frontier province now khyber pakhtunkhwa, pakistan, who had been separated from afghans pashtuns by the durand agreement of 1893, to be able to choose whether to join. At least half a million afghansgovernment forces, taliban fighters, and civilianshave been killed or. Afghanistan war, 2001personal narratives, afghanistan. David cortright this article includes video content. Short stories and novels written about the wars in iraq and afghanistan and the return home from them. It has since turned into one of the longest and most costly wars in u.
Likewise, it can not be won, no matter what the politicians and the generals say. A cultural and political history is an invaluable book. There are no american characters in this book, and the effect is radical. Aug 27, 2019 her new book is bravely situated in afghanistan itself, eroding the myth of the good occupier and of what is termed in the novel kind power. Aug 08, 2018 american troop levels in afghanistan had long lagged far behind those in iraq, and public interest in the war had waned. The afghan president came to believe that he was no more than a tool. Afghanistan is both stalemate and quagmire truthdig. It has since turned into one of the longest and most expensive wars in recent. Dec 18, 2019 he saw moments like last monday coming more than a halfcentury ago and had the good sense to put them in a book of satire i cant help but wish more people used as their guidebook to war. For australia, there is no more important war to examine in detail. The problem with these narratives isnt so much their content, but their premise. Oct 01, 2009 the united states is waging war primarily against the taliban, not al qaeda.
Just how similar was the war in vietnam to the war. In its earliest days, the americanled war in afghanistan appeared to. The afghanistan war and islamic fundamentalism in the late 1970s the government faced increasing popular opposition to its social policies. Directorate s is the highly secret unit of pakistans. America, the taliban, and the war through afghan eyes, was nominated for the pulitzer prize and a national book award. Sep 27, 2011 in 1988, the soviet army left afghanistan after a concerted campaign by the westernbacked mujahideen.
His book about the taliban came to prominence after 911. Masterfully told, no front line will find a place as one of australias finest books on contemporary soldiering. This is a good read if you want to understand that place and the ongoing conflict. No white house wants to lose a war, especially one that has its provenance in 1980 with the decision to arm the afghan mujahedeen against the invading soviet army and in. Best nonfiction war books, around the world one book from each country, best iraq and afghanistan war books, best books on special forces m. British royal marines take part in the clearance of nade ali district of helmand province.
Aug 29, 2017 while afghanistan is a war of sorts, it is not the sort of war in which there is likely to be a decisive moment of victory. Why we couldnt lessons learned will end up in scholarly analysis to identify the decisions made and how they ultimately affected the outcome of initial missions. Gopals book is essential reading for anyone concerned about how america got afghanistan so wrong. Dec 11, 2019 as the french might say, this is no quelle surprise. Lessons from vietnam on leaving afghanistan foreign affairs. History books can be extremely boring, all dates and names jumbling into a. Many policy makers have suggested that the americans failed in afghanistan in part because they were distracted by the war in iraq, but gopal disagrees. Afghanistan lives in our recent past and will continue to occupy our future. Fairweather was confronted by big challenges in writing a study of. A military history from alexander the great to the war. Infidels, and the brotherhood of war in afghanistan sean parnell. But since then, many enduring myths have grown up about the wartorn country. Postwithdrawal puzzle of policy options for india, pakistan and afghanistan postamerican withdrawal from afghanistan scenario after december 2014 and puzzle.
The defeat of taliban forces and the iraqi resistance would take a long time, but success would not end the war because islamist terrorism and its supporters would. In 2014, gopals book on afghanistan, no good men among the living. The good war by jack fairweather penguin books australia. There are graphic descriptions of an adulterous woman being stoned to death based on an execution that michener actually saw and of another public execution where a young man gets his head slowly sawn off with a rusty bayonet again based on an actual event, though. However, this book in not judgmental, serious mistakes were made not in bad. American troop levels in afghanistan had long lagged far behind those in iraq, and public interest in the war had waned.
Rather, afghanistan is best described as an armed policing operation. The best books on afghanistan five books expert recommendations. A military history from alexander the great to the war against the. But as soto began his afghan tour in july 2008, the political conversation. Barfield does not give the united states a way out of afghanistan, but he does provide the context necessary for good.
550 573 1112 674 673 978 1112 653 665 1260 324 948 753 243 336 646 831 1071 503 1169 665 1068 255 907 936 1250 1105 1461 397 1271